Skip to content

Symbolic Reclamations

Summary

Symbolic reclamation is the act of re-using, renaming, or re-purposing a symbol, name, sign, or space originally controlled by an opponent so that it carries the campaign’s meaning instead of the opponent’s. In Sharp’s 198 Methods taxonomy it is method 29, listed under Symbolic Public Acts [source: commons-198-methods].

Body

Reclamation works by inverting the political valence of a symbol without producing a new symbol. The same image, word, or place that signified the opponent now signifies the movement, and the cost of the symbol — its recognisability, its distribution, its emotional weight — was paid by the opponent [source: commons-198-methods]. The tactic is most effective when the original symbol is widely associated with the opponent’s power (a state flag, a corporate logo, a public square named for the regime) and the reclamation is unambiguous (the meaning is not negotiable). Examples include taking a slur and re-using it as self-identification, renaming public monuments and streets under a new political program, and re-purposing state buildings for civic functions. The risk is that the opponent can re-reclaim the symbol if the movement does not consolidate the new meaning through sustained use.

See methods-of-nonviolent-action for the broader method library.

Worked examples

  • west-papua-morning-star-flag-1998 — the West Papuan Morning Star flag is a worked example of symbolic reclamation: the Morning Star was banned under Indonesian rule and re-raised by activists as the central symbol of the self-determination demand.

FAQ

What is symbolic reclamation?

Symbolic reclamation is the act of re-using, renaming, or re-purposing a symbol, name, sign, or space originally controlled by an opponent so that it carries the campaign’s meaning instead of the opponent’s. In Sharp’s 198 Methods taxonomy it is method 29, listed under Symbolic Public Acts [source: commons-198-methods]. Reclamation works by inverting the political valence of a symbol without producing a new symbol.

How does the tactic work?

The same image, word, or place that signified the opponent now signifies the movement, and the cost of the symbol — its recognisability, its distribution, its emotional weight — was paid by the opponent [source: commons-198-methods]. The tactic is most effective when the original symbol is widely associated with the opponent’s power (a state flag, a corporate logo, a public square named for the regime) and the reclamation is unambiguous (the meaning is not negotiable).

What forms does symbolic reclamation take?

Forms include taking a slur and re-using it as self-identification, renaming public monuments and streets under a new political program, and re-purposing state buildings for civic functions. The boundary between slogans, caricatures, and symbols (method 7) and symbolic reclamation (method 29) is the question of who owns the symbol at the moment of use.

What is the worked example?

The West Papuan Morning Star flag is the worked example of symbolic reclamation: the Morning Star was banned under Indonesian rule and re-raised by activists as the central symbol of the self-determination demand. The risk the example surfaces is that the opponent can re-reclaim the symbol if the movement does not consolidate the new meaning through sustained use.

Learn more